The Disadvantages of a 1031 Exchange: What You Should Know

what are the disadvantages of a 1031 exchange?

Did you know failing to follow 1031 exchange rules can end your tax deferral? It might also lead to paying 15% to 20% in federal capital gains taxes. The like-kind exchange offers tax benefits but it’s complicated and risky.

A 1031 exchange lets investors delay capital gains taxes by putting money from one property sale into another. Yet, it has clear limits. Following the IRS’s strict timelines, which include a 45-day identification and a 180-day closing period, means investors need to plan carefully. Using a qualified intermediary adds costs, around $1,250 in the U.S.

Investors face challenges with depreciation schedules too. The reset might help but needs precise records and could lead to depreciation recapture taxed as ordinary income. Also, states like California and Massachusetts don’t always allow tax deferral, adding more complexity.

Risks of 1031 exchanges also involve closer IRS attention, making it vital to keep up with the rules. Investors need a deep understanding of ‘like-kind’ requirements and state laws to succeed in this complex process.

Understanding the Basics of a 1031 Exchange

The 1031 exchange lets investors swap one investment property for another. It’s under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC). This swap can delay paying capital gains taxes, usually 15% to 20%, that you’d have to pay when selling.

To be a like-kind exchange, both properties must be similar and used for business or investment, not personal use. One big plus of a 1031 exchange is it lets investors start depreciation over again. It can also help diversify their investments. But, what are the disadvantages of a 1031 exchange? There are a few important drawbacks to know about.

A big downside is the need for precise tax paperwork and following IRS rules closely. Investors have just 45 days to find a replacement property after selling the old one. They also must close on the new property within 180 days, adding stress to the process.

In some states, like California and Massachusetts, you might not get the same tax deferral benefits, making things harder. A qualified intermediary must guide the exchange, adding extra complexity and costs.

Before the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act in 2017, 1031 exchanges also covered personal property, like franchise licenses. Now, they’re only for real property, which limits options. Plus, both properties must be in the U.S.

Depreciation rules can cause issues too. Swapping like-kind properties, such as buildings, avoids depreciation recapture. But, trading improved land for unimproved land can trigger it. To meet IRS guidelines, if you plan to live in the new property, you must rent it out at a fair market rate for at least 12 months.

The table below summarizes some essential points for a 1031 exchange:

Aspect Detail
Capital Gains Tax Rate 15% to 20%
Identification Period 45 Days
Closing Period 180 Days
State Deferral Variability Varies (e.g., CA, MA)
Uses Depreciation Reset Yes
Frequency of Exchanges Unlimited (if rules followed)

In summary, a 1031 exchange can be great for delaying tax payments and improving your investment portfolio. However, knowing the downsides, including the tricky process, high costs, and tight IRS rules, is key for making the best choices.

Strict Timelines and Regulations

When taking part in a 1031 exchange, investors face tough IRS rules and strict deadlines. It kicks off with a 45-day window to choose new properties after selling the old one. Then, there’s a 180-day deadline to close the deal, needing careful planning to keep the tax benefits.

The deadlines set by the IRS are fixed, so any slip-ups can cause unexpected taxes on profits. Even during events like natural disasters, getting an extension is unlikely. This is why using a Qualified Intermediary is crucial for meeting the complex requirements.

At the state level, the rules can vary, adding more challenges. States like California and Massachusetts have their own conditions on tax deferrals. And dealing with properties in different states brings additional tax concerns, making it important to understand these rules.

If investors do multiple 1031 exchanges, they must watch out for tricky tax issues. For example, a lower mortgage on the new property than on the old one could lead to taxes, even with deferral plans. These factors must be considered early on.

To sum up, the strict timelines and IRS rules demand a deep understanding and smart strategy from investors. This ensures they avoid common mistakes and make the most of the tax deferral opportunities.

Complexity and Higher Future Costs

A 1031 exchange helps avoid capital gains taxes, but it’s not simple. You face 1031 exchange challenges like complex paperwork and higher costs. For example, filling out IRS Form 8824 needs great care. Without a professional, it’s easy to make mistakes, which makes complexity in 1031 exchanges a big issue.

Using a qualified intermediary is also key in a 1031 exchange. This service costs about $1,250 in the U.S. The intermediary handles the money, ensuring you follow IRS rules. You must stick to the 45-Day Rule and the 180-Day Rule, adding to the complexity and cost.

Finding the right replacement property is another 1031 exchange challenge. It can lead to extra costs. State tax differences also add to the effort and expense. Investors must understand and navigate these well.

Let’s look at some typical 1031 exchange costs:

Expense Type Average Cost
Qualified Intermediary Fee $1,250
Identification and Due Diligence of Replacement Property $2,000 – $5,000+
Professional Legal and Tax Services $1,500 – $3,000+
State Tax Variations and Compliance Fees Varies by State

These added expenses show why a 1031 exchange can be pricier. Yet, the prospect of delaying taxes motivates investors to face these challenges.

Risks and Challenges Involved in 1031 Exchanges

The main drawbacks of a 1031 exchange are its complexity and finding a good intermediary. It’s crucial to have one. Investors also struggle with strict timelines. They have 45 days to identify a similar property and 180 days to close on it. These tight deadlines can lead to rushed choices or missed opportunities. Knowing these risks is key to managing them well.

Depreciation recapture is another tricky part of 1032 exchanges. This happens when you swap properties that have depreciated. It could mean unexpected tax bills. It’s essential for investors to understand these rules as they apply to their situations.

Risks Description
Boot Cash left over after acquiring the replacement property is termed as “boot” and may be taxed as partial sales proceeds, adding to the 1031 exchange downsides.
Debt Considerations Loans and debt are crucial factors in 1031 exchanges. A mismatch in liabilities can impact tax implications, which is one of the significant 1031 exchange risks.
Find Suitable Properties Meeting the requirement for “like-kind” property of equal or greater value poses a challenge and potential risk of 1031 exchanges failing.

New rules have made personal property ineligible for 1031 exchanges. Now, only real property qualifies. This change adds complexity. Also, for former homes to qualify, they must be in the U.S. These rules highlight the risks involved in these exchanges.

Another recent update came in 2004 when Congress closed a gap on vacation homes in 1031 exchanges. To qualify, vacation homes must first become rental properties. Getting to grips with these changes is crucial for understanding the risks of 1031 exchanges.


1031 exchanges have their pros, but let’s not forget the cons. They come with complexities and extra costs. For instance, the U.S. government usually takes 15% to 20% in taxes on real estate sales. A 1031 exchange tries to delay these taxes.

But, this strategy needs you to follow strict rules. You have only 45 days to pick a new property and 180 days to finish the deal. This can be really tough.

Not every state in the U.S. lets you delay paying the taxes like the federal government does. For example, people in California and Massachusetts still have to pay state taxes on their gains. Plus, you need to invest all your sales proceeds into your new property and take on at least the same amount of debt. window>

There’s also the risk of rising interest rates making it hard to find a new property in time. Finding a high-value property quickly, like something worth $100 million, adds more pressure. The chance of missing out on better investments and the need for expert help make things even more complex.

So, understanding the cons of a 1031 exchange is key. If you’re thinking about it, learning as much as you can and talking to tax and real estate pros is crucial. Even with the benefits of delaying taxes and growing your portfolio, there are challenges you must navigate carefully.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as tax or legal advice. Always consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions.

Source Links

About the author

Nathan Tarrant

Nathan has worked in financial services, marketing, and strategic business growth for over 30 years. He was the founder and COO of a Queens award-winning financial services company based in the UK, and a capital investment company in Virginia USA..

He operated as a financial & alternative investment advisor to delegates of the UN, World Health Organization, and senior managers of Fortune 500 companies in Geneva, Switzerland, after the 2008 financial crash.

As an avid investor, especially in alternative investments, he runs this blog, sharing his growing experience and views on alternative investments. You can see Nathan's full profile at his personal website
You can read his full bio on our about us page

Follow us

Don't be shy, get in touch. We love meeting interesting people and making new friends.


We are required by the FTC to inform you that the content on this website is not financial advice and should not be viewed as such. When it comes to investing of any type, you should always do your own research and speak with a professional financial advisor before making any decisions financially. The owners of this website may be paid to recommend American Hartford Gold or other companies. The content on this website, including any positive reviews of Goldco and other reviews, may not be neutral or independent.

American Hartford Gold Banner